Roofing question

Should a 20 year old roof be replaced?

The short answer

Not on age alone. A 20 year old roof needs replacing when its condition says so, not when a birthday comes. Home inspectors estimate about 20 years for basic 3-tab asphalt shingles and about 30 years for architectural shingles, so a 3-tab roof at 20 is near the end of its expected life. But heat, hail and upkeep move that number a lot. Hot climates wear asphalt out faster, and hail can shorten a roof’s life. Ask a roofer to inspect the roof and show you photos of what they find: worn granules, deep or widespread cracks, water stains or sagging in the decking, or leaks. If the damage is in one area, a repair may give you more years.

  • Condition decides, not age: get an inspection with photos.
  • Inspectors estimate about 20 years for 3-tab shingles and about 30 for architectural.
  • Heat and hail shorten roof life, so the same roof ages faster in some places.
  • Insurance pays for storm damage, not for a roof that is only old.

Updated

Weather sets the pace

InterNACHI, the home inspectors’ association, says roof life depends on local weather, building design, material quality and upkeep, and that hot climates sharply cut asphalt shingle life. IBHS, a nonprofit research group, says hail can damage roof coverings and shorten the life of a roof.

The table shows the metros in our data with the most days of large hail. A 20 year old roof in one of these places has likely taken more hits than the same roof in a quiet area. See all metros in our hail days research.

Source: NOAA NCEI Storm Events Database, 2016 to 2025. Days with at least one hail report within 15 miles of the metro's main city. These are days with reports, not counts of damaged roofs, and a quiet record does not mean no risk.
MetroHail daysDays with hail 1 inch+Last 1 inch+ hail
Rapid City, SD1211022025
Colorado Springs, CO99892025
Oklahoma City, OK88712025
Amarillo, TX75602025
Wichita, KS74582025
Cheyenne, WY68582025
Lawton, OK62502025
Denver-Aurora-Centennial, CO62492025
Lubbock, TX57492025
Tulsa, OK69482025

Signs a roof is near the end

  • Bare spots where granules have worn away. Some granule loss is normal aging; a lot of it, early, is a warning.
  • Cracks in the shingle surface that have grown deep and spread. InterNACHI says this cracking often starts after 10 or 12 years, sooner in harsh climates.
  • Water stains on the underside of the roof deck, or a deck that sags, seen from the attic.
  • Damage at the ridge caps. IBHS says they are among the parts of a shingle roof most open to hail damage.

One or two of these in one area may call for a repair. Many of them across the roof point to a replacement. Our guide to repair or replacement walks through the choice.

Insurance and an old roof

The Texas Department of Insurance says your insurer will not pay for a new roof just because it is old or worn out, and that some insurers switch an aging roof to actual cash value. The NAIC says upkeep, such as fixing a roof when it starts to leak, is the owner’s job. So if a storm hit, ask your insurer about a claim. If the roof is only worn, the cost is yours.

Before you decide

  1. Get an inspection. NRCA, the roofing contractors’ association, says regular inspections find problems early, before they become leaks.
  2. Ask the roofer to show you photos and to say in writing whether a repair would last.
  3. Get two or three written prices. Our guides cover what a new roof costs and how to compare estimates.

Find a roofer near you

Find roofers by state or search by city or ZIP.

Sources

We checked these pages in November 2026. Rules and prices change, and they differ by state and city. This page is general information. It is not legal, insurance or financial advice.