Roofing question

Are hail resistant shingles worth it?

The short answer

They are often worth it where hail is common, and less so where it is rare. Hail-resistant shingles carry a Class 4 rating under the UL 2218 test, the top class. They are built to take harder hits than standard shingles, but they are not hail-proof, and products differ. Many insurers give a discount for impact-resistant roofing, and in Texas the state insurance department says a Class 4 roof gets the highest credit. Each insurer sets the amount. So the answer comes down to three numbers: the extra price from your roofer, the yearly credit from your insurer, and how often hail hits where you live. Ask your roofer to price the roof both ways, and ask your agent what the credit would be.

  • Class 4 is the top rating in the UL 2218 hail test.
  • Class 4 is not hail-proof, and independent tests show products differ.
  • Many insurers give a credit for impact-resistant roofing; each sets its own amount.
  • Weigh the extra price against the credit and how often hail hits your area.

Updated

What Class 4 means

UL 2218 drops steel balls on a roofing sample. Class 1 uses a 1.25 inch ball, Class 2 a 1.50 inch ball, Class 3 a 1.75 inch ball and Class 4 a 2 inch ball. Each ball falls from the height that gives it the energy of a hailstone of the same size. A shingle passes if no crack or tear shows on its back. Dents and crushed or lost granules on top do not count as a failure.

So a Class 4 shingle can still show marks after a storm. IBHS, a nonprofit research group, also rates shingles with lab-made hailstones and grades dents, tears and granule loss. In its 2025 ratings, most products earned "Good" and none earned "Excellent". IBHS does not recommend a product rated "Marginal" or "Poor" where hail falls.

Where the case is strongest

The table shows the metros in our data with the most days of hail 1 inch or larger. In places like these, a roof is likely to take several hits. IBHS also found that standard shingles lose much of their hail resistance between 5 and 10 years of age. See every metro in our hail days research.

Source: NOAA NCEI Storm Events Database, 2016 to 2025. Days with at least one hail report within 15 miles of the metro's main city. These are days with reports, not counts of damaged roofs, and a quiet record does not mean no risk.
MetroHail daysDays with hail 1 inch+Last 1 inch+ hail
Rapid City, SD1211022025
Colorado Springs, CO99892025
Oklahoma City, OK88712025
Amarillo, TX75602025
Wichita, KS74582025
Cheyenne, WY68582025
Lawton, OK62502025
Denver-Aurora-Centennial, CO62492025
Lubbock, TX57492025
Tulsa, OK69482025

Insurance credits and FORTIFIED

The Oklahoma Insurance Department says many insurers give a discount for impact-resistant roofing. The Texas Department of Insurance says each insurer sets its own credit, and that the roofer fills out a state form after installing the roof. Some policies also leave out cosmetic hail damage, which changes only how the roof looks, so ask your agent how your policy treats it.

In three states in our records, state law requires a discount for a home built or retrofitted to the IBHS FORTIFIED standard. FORTIFIED asks for a sealed roof deck and stronger nailing. Its optional hail add-on asks for shingles rated "Good" or "Excellent" by IBHS.

Source: each state's own licensing board, statute or consumer pages, listed on its page in our roofing license guide. Read October 2026. A state not in this table may still have rules; we found none.
StateRoof insurance ruleOfficial source
AlabamaAlabama law makes insurers give a discount on a policy with wind coverage for a home built or retrofitted to an IBHS FORTIFIED standard. If insurance will pay for your roof, you can cancel the roofing contract before midnight on the fifth business day after your insurer tells you in writing that all or part of the claim is not covered, or will not cover the contract price. The roofer may not require payment until those five days end, except for emergency work you confirmed in writing was needed.alison.legislature.state.al.us, source 2
LouisianaInsurers must offer an add-on that pays to upgrade to a FORTIFIED roof when a covered claim needs a new roof, and state law requires insurers to give a premium discount for a FORTIFIED roof. An IBHS FORTIFIED certificate is the only paper you need for that discount. A seller may not waive, absorb or rebate your deductible without your insurer's consent.www.legis.la.gov, source 2, source 3, source 4, source 5
MississippiThe Mississippi Insurance Department says state law requires insurers to give discounts for homes built or retrofitted to IBHS FORTIFIED standards. A residential roofing contractor may not pay or rebate your deductible. If insurance will pay, you can cancel the roof contract within three business days after your insurer tells you in writing that all or part of the claim is not covered.www.mid.ms.gov, source 2

To compare the full cost of a roof, see our guides to what a new roof costs and metal or shingle roofs.

Find a roofer near you

Find roofers by state or search by city or ZIP.

Sources

We checked these pages in November 2026. Rules and prices change, and they differ by state and city. This page is general information. It is not legal, insurance or financial advice.